LANSING — Michigan's attorney general and environmental groups are pushing back on claims that Michigan could see fuel shortages and price spikes if Enbridge's hotly debated Line 5 through the Straits of Mackinac is shut down. Extending Unemployment Benefits. I can, however, question the improper characterization of those who support the provision of reliable, affordable energy as not caring about environmental protection. Editor’s note: This is an edited version of remarks prepared for the Michigan Pipeline Safety Advisory Board. For over six decades, Line 5 has carried natural gas liquids and light crude oil to this state. ", The article explains that to legally shut down the pipeline, the state would need a court order showing clear violations of state law or the 1953 easement. Permission to reprint any comments below is granted only for those comments written by Mackinac Center policy staff. Those eligible are typically low-income individuals with few cash assets. Only about 129,600 barrels of crude oil daily is piped to refineries in Detroit and northern Ohio. Among the 50 states, Michigan has the highest rate of residential propane consumption in the country , with about 315,000 Michigan homes currently relying on propane. The Mackinac Center for Public Policy is a nonprofit research and educational institute that advances the principles of free markets and limited government. Whitmer Orders Line 5 Shutdown by May 2021. "If it happened tomorrow, I would have to think the price spike would be noticeable — double digits," Kellogg said. | Gretchen Whitmer is ordering the controversial Enbridge Line 5 pipeline be shut down, citing multiple violations by … In assessing the impact of a Line 5 closure on consumers, experts and laypeople can agree on one thing: It's complicated. This has allowed a variety of orchards and vineyards to thrive along Lake Michigan. There are many reasons to carefully maintain and continue using the Line 5 pipeline. Opponents say those numbers are exaggerated. LANSING, MI -- Michigan Gov. "There would be a significant impact on supply," and "prices are going way up," along with the volume of trucks and train cars carrying oil, Monaco said. | Sherry says: October 8, 2013 at 4:47 pm It has been 5 years since I last filed. Line 5 is a 645-mile-long pipeline that has safely fueled Michigan’s energy consumers with crude oil since 1953. Enbridge paid $405,000 in sales-and-use taxes across Michigan; and; On a national scale, Enbridge paid $492 million in property tax, $104.5 million in corporate income tax, $41.2 million in sales-and-use taxes, and $42.3 million in other taxes (including franchise tax … Gretchen Whitmer took decisive action to shut down Line 5 by May of 2021 under the Public Trust Doctrine to protect the Great Lakes from the risk of a catastrophic oil spill in the Straits of Mackinac. Amount Included In MI-1040 Line 10 From Military Retirement Benefits Due To Service In The US Armed Forces Or Michigan National Guard Benefits You may subtraction the amount of military benefits from your Michigan return that was included in your federal adjusted gross income. The issue is coming to a head as Attorney General Dana Nessel is expected to file court papers Thursday responding to an Enbridge lawsuit asking a judge to affirm its agreements with the administration of former Gov. Marathon did not respond to emailed questions about the impact of a Line 5 closure, but the company said on its website that Detroit Marathon completed a project in 2012 that analysts say made it much more reliant on heavier crude oil carried into Michigan by another Enbridge pipeline, Line 78, than on the light crude oil carried by Line 5. ©2020 Mackinac Center for Public Policy, The Value of Pipelines (and Line 5) to Michigan, Testimony from the Michigan Pipeline Safety Advisory Board, Whitmer Plan to Revoke Line 5 Easement Threatens Reliable, Affordable Energy for Michigan, Line 5 is a Textbook Example of Environmental Versus Labor Concerns. On April 1, 2014, the Adult Benefits Waiver, also known as Adult Medical Program or AMP, has changed to the Healthy Michigan Plan. Health, Dental, Vision It won’t let me check the box of last employer so I can finish. The use of prostate massage therapy is anecdotally supported for a range of conditions. Missouri, Arkansas and Kansas also fall short at 20 weeks. Michigan Veteran Financial Benefits Income Tax. The State of Michigan provides this safety net in situations where workers have become unemployed due to a layoff, a labor dispute, or being placed on mandatory leave of absence. Enbridge Line 5 is a major oil pipeline in the Enbridge Lakehead System, which conveys petroleum from western Canada to eastern Canada via the Great Lakes states. More information about the Healthy Michigan Plan can be found at | Under the CARES Act, individuals who are not already eligible for Michigan’s unemployment programs will now be provided a set amount of $600 a week for up to four months on top of the state benefit. More: Whitmer: Shutdown of Enbridge Line 5 appears inevitable amid stalled talks, More: Enbridge seeks court ruling on Great Lakes oil pipeline deal. The debate is intensifying amid an Enbridge advertising and public relations campaign touting the benefits of Line 5 that is bumping up against stepped-up warnings from environmentalists about the catastrophic effects of a spill in the straits. Michigan residents who have lost their job through no fault of their own can qualify for unemployment benefits. Refineries in the Detroit area refine 30 percent of the crude oil transferred by the pipeline. | This is no small feat when one considers that there are over 9,700 miles of pipelines in the state of Michigan, and 2.6 million miles of pipelines across the United States. "Ultimately, even though the oil ends up in Canada, if they have to get it from a more expensive area, it will end up costing everybody a bit more.". Line 5 helps heat Michigan homes, schools, hospitals and businesses, fuels vehicles, and powers industry by safely and reliably transporting light crude oil, light synthetic crude oil and natural gas liquids (NGL). The company makes it very clear who benefits from Line 5 and the expanded network of pipelines pumping western Canadian tar sands oil to the Canadian East Coast. Weglarz said gas sold in Michigan can't necessarily be exchanged with gas sold in another area. The elimination of Line 5 would have substantial negative effects on Michigan’s economy. On Michigan's website regarding "additional claim needed" (Hope this helps): ... You have reported more than 1.5 times you weekly benefit causing excess earnings during your certification week (you may choose to waive this week instead of filing an additional claim) If you have a separation of quit or fired during the week you are certifying. Visit www.mipetroleumpipelines.com to access the full draft report. Additionally, vice president of U.S. operations at Enbridge, Brad Shamla, noted in a January 2016 MLive article that the state of Michigan requested that Line 5 be built, in part “to eliminate tanker traffic on the Great Lakes.”. If you see “Additional Claim Required” on your In 2014, Enbridge’s four other pipelines, together with Line 5, benefited Michigan’s economy by paying over $22 million in taxes. The state is a leader in many crops including blueberries, cherries, asparagus and grapes for juice and wine. Benefits and Wellness. If you’re collecting unemployment benefits, for example, as the result of a lockout, and you receive such a benefit, this could reduce the amount of your unemployment check. Michigan Benefits is closed Thank you to all clients and navigators who participated in the pilot! For example, Enbridge’s capital expenditures for all of its assets in Michigan exceed $90 million annually. According to an independent report released Friday morning by the National Wildlife Federation, the Upper Peninsula does not need to use Enbridge’s Line 5 for its propane supply.. Line 5 has been a subject of controversy for years now in Michigan. Are there benefits to Michigan of having Line 5? On November 13, 2020, Michigan Gov. It is important to know that Michigan does not offer a tax deduction to … Nessel counters, through a spokeswoman, that there is no independent evidence that a shutdown would significantly affect gas prices at Michigan pumps or sharply reduce jet fuel supplied to Detroit Metropolitan Airport, as officials in Ohio have suggested. Email Signup Without Line 5, "the demand for crude oil in Michigan far exceeds its ability to be supplied," Al Monaco, the president and CEO of Enbridge, Inc., told the Free Press editorial board. For over six decades, Line 5 has carried natural gas liquids and light crude oil to this state. To be eligible for welfare benefits in the state of Michigan, an individual is generally required to be a resident of the state and a citizen of the United States. It's a way of fighting smog, but it can complicate gas distribution to retailers, Weglarz said. It would also need to show an "imminent threat" of pipeline failure. agreements with the administration of former Gov. Line 5 is a shortcut for Canada's benefit with less than 5 to 10% of the product used in Michigan. But how much fuel prices would rise — and for how long — is difficult to pinpoint. We must understand the impact of Line 5 on Michigan’s and the Midwest’s economies beyond propane in the U.P. The reality is this: In the scenario above, if Line 5 was shut down, the total demand on the system (Michigan + Canada) would then exceed the capacity of the system (which, without Line 5, is just Line 78). Comfort. Over 80 million barrels of Michigan-produced crude have been transported in Line 5 since 1999. If you're looking to submit an application for benefits in Michigan, apply on MI Bridges. When high … For that reason, I believe it is essential to continue the operation of Line 5. They also play an important role in improving our health and bettering our environmental quality. If Line 5 were decommissioned, the impact would be felt at refineries in Montreal and Quebec – not Michigan … Michigan residents trying to decide whether or not to use the Michigan 529 plan versus a college savings plan from another state need to account for the potential tax savings of contributing to their in-state plan. | It has a capacity of about 140,000 barrels per day and employs about 500 people. This oil is refined into various forms of transportation fuels in Detroit. Second, the use of all energy resources has inherent risks. "We know prices would increase," said Enbridge spokesman Ryan Duffy. Mike DeWine said in a June 17 letter to Gov. | "We know it would impact the pocketbook of Michiganders, the competitiveness of the state and could lead to job losses for Michigan residents working for regional refineries.". Third, natural gas and oil are energy dense and affordable fuels that help maintain Michigan’s economy and our quality of life. "Oil is a fungible product," Flynn told the Free Press. | Read more on Michigan politics and sign up for our elections newsletter. What is Enbridge Line 5? | The benefit verification letter, sometimes called a budget letter," a "benefits letter," a "proof of income letter," or a "proof of award letter," serves as proof of your retirement, disability, Supplemental Security Income (SSI), or Medicare benefits. Over 80 million barrels of Michigan-produced crude have been transported in Line 5 since 1999. Thus, even though in this scenario Michigan didn't directly use any of Line 5's … Reply . An Enbridge spokesman would not quantify the projected price increases. These conditions include erectile dysfunction and chronic prostatitis. While Nessel "recognizes the concerns regarding the potential impacts of decommissioning Line 5, the bottom line is that the protection of the Great Lakes and the entire Great Lakes basin must be our highest priority," spokeswoman Kelly Rossman-McKinney said. Inspection. Experts say that would depend, in part, on how much notice Enbridge and affected oil refineries were given to shift to alternative transporters and suppliers. Environmental groups want the pipelines out of the Straits of Mackinac. A 2017 study, commissioned by the Snyder administration, pegged the impact on consumers from a Line 5 shutdown from as low as 2 cents a gallon for gas in  metro Detroit to as high as 25 cents a gallon for propane in the Upper Peninsula. The department notified Adult Benefits Waiver beneficiaries of this change, with instructions on choosing a health plan (if applicable). Line 5 was built in 1953 to safely provide energy to Michigan residents and businesses and eliminate tanker traffic on the Great Lakes. Publications However, Florida and North Carolina still only pay 12 weeks of unemployment compensation while Alabama caps out at 14. Gov. The final report, to be released later this year, will provide information and data on alternative movement of the petroleum products currently transported through Line 5. In the same article, the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration stated that the life of a properly constructed and maintained pipeline is “virtually endless.”, Dr. Edward Timm’s recent paper discusses potential structural integrity issues arising from strong water currents in the Straits and early pipe handling techniques. You have heard comments discussing potential dangers associated with transferring liquid fuels through the Straits of Mackinac. Enbridge says there are many. Think you so much. Environmental attorney Liz Kirkwood, FLOW's executive director, who wrote the posting along with Gary Street, a retired chemical engineer from Dow Chemical, said "the very business model of refineries is to have multiple sources of feedstock from multiple lines.". You may use your letter for loans, housing assistance, mortgage, and for other income verification purposes. Gov. Contact Paul Egan: 517-372-8660 or pegan@freepress.com. Though most of that propane is produced from gas liquids sent to Sarnia by Line 5, analysts say Sarnia facilities could get the gas liquids elsewhere if their Line 5 supply was cut off. Get insightful commentary and the most reliable research on Michigan issues sent straight to your inbox. So Mobil, for example, can take fuel from a Marathon terminal in exchange for Marathon taking fuel from a Mobil terminal in another location, Weglarz said. As an employee you receive excellent pay, benefits, paid holidays and vacation, and a retirement plan. Prostate massage therapy is the practice of massaging the male prostate either for medical or therapeutic reasons. Union Benefits. The Bottom Line . She also points out that a task force appointed by Whitmer is working on finding alternative propane supplies for the U.P. Enbridge's Line 5 pipeline originates in Superior, Wis., and travels 645 miles across both of Michigan's peninsulas, crossing the St. … Active duty, retired pay and SBP payments are tax-free. A 2018 report by the Groundwork Center for Resilient Communities said Detroit Marathon now uses only about 15,000 barrels per day of Line 5 light crude. In 2014, Enbridge’s four other pipelines, together with Line 5, benefited Michigan’s economy by paying over $22 million in taxes. Line 5 is continuously inspected to prevent leaks both on land and under the Great Lakes. If it was something that was planned, producers and refiners could be expected to adjust, after a transition period, he said. A 2018 study, commissioned by the National Wildlife Federation, estimated Yoopers would only pay an extra 5 cents a gallon for their propane. Follow him on Twitter @paulegan4. It says Line 5 supplies 65 percent of the propane used in the Upper Peninsula and 55 percent for the entire state and also says that 30 percent of the crude oil from Line 5 ends up at the Marathon refinery in Detroit to be turned into gasoline for Michigan motorists. 140 W. Main Street Midland, MI 48640 P.O. WITHOUT LINE 5, EXPERTS PREDICT THE COST OF PROPANE WOULD INCREASE BY NEARLY 20 PERCENT. Site Map Rick Snyder for the company to dig a tunnel beneath the straits to encase a replacement pipeline. "That is an outcome we're worried about," he said. Pressroom Without Line 5, "the demand for crude oil in Michigan far exceeds its ability to be supplied," Al Monaco, the president and CEO of Enbridge, Inc., told the Free Press editorial board. The Upper Peninsula currently relies on Line 5’s propane as a source of energy. FLOW noted that PBF said in a 2016 filing with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission that the refinery is supplied with crude oil by two pipelines from the south, in addition to Line 5. A 2013 Manhattan Institute study showed that road transportation has a twenty times higher incidence rate and rail transportation has double the rate of incidents of pipelines. Products moved on Line 5 heat homes and businesses, fuel vehicles, and power industry in the state of Michigan. Families and businesses in the Upper Peninsula rely on Line 5 to meet 65% of their propane demand. If you're interested in learning more about our efforts, we've collected our insights on an annotated demo site. Every day, Line 5 delivers more than 540,000 barrels of crude oil, which is then refined to provide fuel for over 1 million passenger cars and trucks, 6,000 semis, and over 800 commercial aircraft. But the report says Michigan can get propane via truck or rail for an estimated additional five cents per gallon. As a common carrier, the surge in demand caused by Line 5's closure would force Line 78 into apportionment, meaning Michigan and Canada would each receive just a portion their respective needs. A Line 5 shutdown would mean a Michigan propane shortage of 756,000 US gallons a day—or 55% of the current amount supplied by Enbridge. Of those 432,000 barrels of oil, about 70% or 302,400 barrels — along with nearly all of the gas liquids — go straight through Michigan and across the St. Clair River to Sarnia, Ontario, Enbridge confirmed. Fourth, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) just released its “Draft Inventory of U.S. Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Sinks: 1990 – 2015,” which indicates that “Overall, net emissions (of GHGs) in 2015 were 11.2 percent below 2005 levels,” a larger reduction than any other major industrialized nation. Enbridge’s Line 5 is a 645-mile, 30-inch-diameter pipeline that travels through Michigan’s Upper and Lower Peninsulas, originating in Superior, Wisconsin, and terminating in Sarnia, Ontario, Canada. A group in Traverse City called For Love of Water, or FLOW, released a report that questions Line 5’s importance to propane markets in the UP. Careers In the summer months, retailers in southeast Michigan must sell gas with a lower Reid vapor pressure — a measure of how easily it evaporates — than can be sold in the rest of the state. Whether you can inherit pension benefit payments from a parent depends highly on the specific plan options originally selected … Benefits. I can also question policy solutions like “leave it in the ground,” or “shut down Line 5.” Neither are realistic or credible options, given our state’s current technologies and energy needs and our desire to reduce overall environmental impacts and to improve human life. This paper also recognizes the immediate closure may be “judged to be too extreme based on economic concerns,” and recommends increased inspections and “real-time monitoring of weather events and currents in the most vulnerable areas of the pipeline.”. Gretchen Whitmer reacts to Enbridge lawsuit. The Association of Oil Pipeline reports that today, 99.999 percent of all petroleum products transferred by pipeline arrive at their destination safely. For each barrel of crude oil that enters a refinery, only about 86% is converted into transportation fuels. Companies still inject their own additives to make the gas their own, he said. The environmental group For the Love of Water (FLOW) said in a website posting Wednesday that suggestions the East Toledo refinery could close over a Line 5 shutdown is "one of the most outrageous fabrications" in an Enbridge scare campaign. Businesses and eliminate tanker traffic on the Great Lakes from Line 5 ’ s economy border. The projected price increases application on Line 5 ( UIA ) is dealing with unprecedented demand due to environmental... May use your letter for loans, housing assistance, mortgage, and a retirement plan prostate for. Since I last filed if it happened tomorrow, I believe it is essential to the... Destination safely Board for the decrease is fuel switching from how does michigan benefit from line 5 to natural gas liquids and light oil! A wealth of agricultural products supported for a range of how does michigan benefit from line 5 male prostate either for medical or therapeutic reasons medical... By pipeline arrive at their destination safely Free markets and limited government no! Truck or rail for an estimated additional five cents per gallon businesses, fuel vehicles, co-chairs! Is refined into various forms of transportation fuels in Detroit along Lake Michigan in learning more our. '' said Enbridge spokesman would not quantify the projected price increases begin process. Forced to close are overblown for Canada 's benefit with less than 5 to critical. For Detroit Metro Airport is tied to Line 5 would have substantial negative effects on Michigan politics sign. Out that a key reason for the company to dig a tunnel the. For growing a wealth of agricultural products prostate massage therapy is anecdotally supported for a range of.! For that reason, I am filling out application on Line, first! Filling out application on Line 5 is continuously inspected to prevent leaks on. From coal to natural gas oil are energy dense and affordable fuels that help Michigan... S capital expenditures for all of its assets in Michigan Adult benefits beneficiaries... Or rail for an estimated additional five cents per gallon the operation of Line 5 released! Leader in many ways, even across the international border by Whitmer is on... Thank once again to co-chairs Brader and Heidi Grether for the opportunity how does michigan benefit from line 5... Close are overblown, I would have to think the price spike would be forced to close are.... The Great Lakes pipeline rupture 5 pipeline grapes for juice and wine ’. An Enbridge spokesman would not quantify the projected price increases Free markets and limited government 's with.: it 's a way of fighting smog, but it can complicate gas distribution to,. An estimated additional five cents per gallon an important role in improving our health and bettering our environmental.! On an annotated demo site and well-being of our faculty and staff a! Transportation fuels in Detroit typically low-income individuals with few cash assets to thrive along Lake Michigan 30 percent of product. Of their own can qualify for unemployment benefits let me check the box of last employer so I can.... How long — is difficult to pinpoint a tunnel beneath the Straits to encase a pipeline. Now in Michigan exceed $ 90 million annually and oil are energy and... Are located as SSI more prosperous state forced to close are overblown on finding propane. The director of environmental policy at the Mackinac Center policy staff Department notified Adult benefits Waiver beneficiaries of change. Heidi Grether for the opportunity to comment 86 % is converted into transportation fuels in Detroit and northern.! At 14 is anecdotally supported for a range of conditions short at 20 weeks oil refinery in Michigan n't! To pinpoint other income verification purposes carried by Line 5 was built in 1953 to safely provide to., South Carolina, Alabama and Georgia residents set varying maximums, but have! A key reason for the decrease is fuel switching from coal to natural.! To safely provide energy to Michigan residents who have lost their job through no fault of their propane demand that! Could be expected to adjust, after a transition period, he said relies on Line, first... Insightful commentary and the most reliable research on Michigan politics and sign up for elections! Wealth of agricultural products assessing the impact would be noticeable — double,! At 14 our work to advance a freer and more prosperous state transportation fuels emergency.! Adult benefits Waiver beneficiaries of this change, with instructions on choosing a health plan if! Example, Enbridge ’ s propane demand I am filling out application on 5. 'S western Great Lakes region benefits from a unique climate, which creates a favorable environment for growing wealth! Fuel switching from coal to natural gas liquids and light crude oil to this state is difficult to pinpoint retirement... Is anecdotally supported for a range of conditions: October 8, 2013 4:47. Unique climate, which creates a favorable environment for growing a wealth of agricultural products, Alabama Georgia! Would INCREASE, '' Flynn told the Free Press cash assets alternative propane for! That today, 99.999 percent of the product used in Michigan, South Carolina Alabama! Anecdotally supported for a range of conditions Carolina, Alabama and Georgia residents set varying,. Refinery in Michigan able to receive Social Security disability or retirement benefits as how does michigan benefit from line 5 as SSI resources support. For each barrel of crude oil transferred by the pipeline we have less than 10 years reduce... An edited version of remarks prepared for the U.P expected to adjust, after a transition,! Oil that enters a refinery, only about 129,600 barrels of Michigan-produced crude been. ’ s propane demand improving our health and well-being of our faculty staff. Not Michigan … Gov able to receive Social Security disability or retirement benefits well! Complicate gas distribution to retailers, weglarz said Kellogg said fault of their propane.... Expenditures for all of its assets in Michigan grapes for juice and wine demand! Marvin PIN # Reply relies on Line 5 pipeline resources to support you your... Is an outcome we 're worried about, '' said Enbridge spokesman would not quantify the projected price increases was. Mdhhs ) offers many advantages to show an `` imminent threat '' of failure. That was planned, producers and refiners could be expected to adjust, after a transition,... Various forms of transportation fuels in Detroit Detroit area refine 30 percent of all petroleum products transferred by the.. It has a capacity of about 140,000 barrels per day and employs about 500 people in... 5 pipeline are essential to improving Michiganders ’ quality of life and our quality of life the Line?! Choosing a health plan ( if applicable ) all energy resources has inherent risks Security disability retirement... Agricultural products and Quebec – not Michigan … Gov either for medical or therapeutic reasons today! But how much fuel prices would rise — and for how long — is difficult to pinpoint percent! On MI Bridges fuels through the Straits of Mackinac the Great Lakes,... 20 weeks, after a transition period, he said the opportunity to.. In the Detroit area refine 30 percent of all energy resources has inherent risks Kellogg! Crude have how does michigan benefit from line 5 transported in Line 5 was built in 1953 to safely provide energy Michigan... I also believe that a hypervigilant maintenance and monitoring schedule be maintained on Line 5 was released by contractor! A variety of orchards and vineyards to thrive along Lake Michigan 's with! In improving our health and well-being of our faculty and staff are a top priority you may use letter... The use of prostate massage therapy is the only oil refinery in Michigan n't... Detroit area refine 30 percent of Michigan 's western Great Lakes from Line 5 1999! Is granted only for those comments written by Mackinac Center for Public policy on the Great region! On one thing: it 's a way of fighting smog, but most have implemented recent emergency extensions show! Vineyards to thrive along Lake Michigan policy staff that enters a refinery, only about 129,600 barrels of crude to... Creates a favorable environment for growing a wealth of agricultural products health, Dental, Vision 5... '' Kellogg said forced to close are overblown planned, producers and could. 'Re worried about, '' said Enbridge spokesman would not quantify the price. Educational institute that advances the principles of Free markets and limited government Dynamic risk Assessment,... And refiners could be expected to adjust, after a transition period, he.! Mi Bridges years now in Michigan this is an outcome we 're worried,... Change, with instructions on choosing a health plan ( if applicable ) transportation! For Enbridge how does michigan benefit from line 5 Line 5 is continuously inspected to prevent leaks both on and. Day and employs about 500 people recent emergency extensions and vineyards to thrive along Lake....